Article: 20110501019

Title: MYSTICAL VIBRATIONS

20110501019
900041000019
200050_20110501_000019.xml
MYSTICAL VIBRATIONS
0032-1478
Playboy
HMH Publishing Co., Inc.
Letters to the Editor
Dear Playboy
13
13,14
article
Deepak Chopra says it angers him that I and other skeptics call him Dr. Woo and accuse him of practicing "woo woo." But the first time I heard this phrase used in association with Chopra was from Deepak himself. Woo woo is the practice of string­ing together scientific-sounding but meaningless words, such as "acausal non­local superposition of possibilities" and "quantum consciousness." Here's a gem of Deepakese from a debate we had on Larry King Live about "near-death experiences": "There are traditions that say the in-body experience is a socially induced collective hallucination. We do not exist in the body. The body exists in us. We do not exist in the world. The world exists in us." Or this nugget: "Birth and death are space-time events in the continuum of life. So the opposite of life is not death. The oppo­site of death is birth. And the opposite of birth is death. And life is the continuum of birth and death, which goes on and on." Unless such concepts can be attributed to an underlying causal mechanism in the brain subject to scientific testing, they are not science but pseudoscience.
13
14

Deepak Chopra says it angers him that I and other skeptics call him Dr. Woo and accuse him of practicing "woo woo." But the first time I heard this phrase used in association with Chopra was from Deepak himself. Woo woo is the practice of string­ing together scientific-sounding but meaningless words, such as "acausal non­local superposition of possibilities" and "quantum consciousness." Here's a gem of Deepakese from a debate we had on Larry King Live about "near-death experiences": "There are traditions that say the in-body experience is a socially induced collective hallucination. We do not exist in the body. The body exists in us. We do not exist in the world. The world exists in us." Or this nugget: "Birth and death are space-time events in the continuum of life. So the opposite of life is not death. The oppo­site of death is birth. And the opposite of birth is death. And life is the continuum of birth and death, which goes on and on." Unless such concepts can be attributed to an underlying causal mechanism in the brain subject to scientific testing, they are not science but pseudoscience.

Michael Shermer Altadena, California

Shermer is executive director of the Skeptics Society (skeplic.com) and author of Why People

Believe Weird Things, Why Darwin Matters and The Believing Brain.

I am disappointed that Chopra, who has contributed so much to the evolu­tion of our culture, does not mention the source of much of his knowledge and insight, namely Maharishi Mahesh Yogi and Transcendental Meditation. You note in the introduction that "celebrities liked him, too: Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, Jackie Onassis...all came calling," but Mahari­shi certainly did not "come calling" to Chopra. It was precisely the opposite.

Bill Schieve

Fort Bragg, California

While I found much to like in Chopra's observations on pornography and Fox News, most of the interview left me cold. He dismisses critics such as Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens and Richard Dawkins as "high school teachers" ped­dling "old science." What does that even mean? When you make claims regarding people's health and well-being you need to have evidence. Vague pronouncements supported by anecdotes are the foun­dation of religion but have no place in science. With regard to Chopra's belief that Barack Obama should be a one-term president, I agree with Bill Maher, who says anyone who takes this position must say who should replace him. The alterna­tives range from bad to awful to appalling. And as far as I can tell, none is able to unblock a chakra.

Andrew McEwan Dayton, Ohio